First the good news: what the mystery-shop results mean

The mystery-shop study looked at what a homeowner sees when they ask about replacing a failed septic tank at a four-bedroom house. Shoppers supplied a test postcode only, with no house number. This article sets out what the mystery-shop results suggest for suppliers and installers. These are readings of small, dated samples, not proof of how the whole market behaves.
The study covered UK off-mains wastewater firms in October and November 2026. Firms are anonymised and the figures are a dated snapshot. It is not a ranking of any firm.
First the good news

On the phone, 14 of 16 valid suppliers answered by a person in working hours. At installers, a person answered at least once at 24 of 45 valid firms, after retries, and the web form replies that arrived had a median of one hour. 12 of 14 valid merchant branches also answered by phone. The gaps are in what happens next.
What the mystery-shop results suggest for suppliers
- The first contact often goes to a recording out of hours. In out-of-hours tests, 10 of 11 suppliers reached a recording or voicemail. 5 of 11 promised a next step.
- Reply speed varies widely. Web form replies took from about 8 minutes to about 90 hours. At least 11 of 15 valid firms replied with a human.
- A price needs to say what it covers. 5 firms gave a price, estimate or ballpark by web form, from £1,682 to £15,768. The prices covered different scopes. A homeowner cannot easily compare them.
- The handoff is where the enquiry can slow down. One sizing tool introduced an installer 1 hour 44 minutes after a repeat submission. At one supplier, two salespeople wrote to the same enquirer on the same day.
What it suggests for installers
- Most installers who answered needed more details. Of 24 reached by phone, at least 15 needed details first and at least 13 wanted a site visit. Qualifying by hand takes time on every enquiry.
- Few gave a number. 6 of the 24 gave a price or ballpark. By web form, 2 of 22 replies gave a ballpark, with the scope not stated.
- Some installers replied quickly by web form. By 13:20 UK time on 12 November 2026, 22 of 47 submissions had received a reply. The median for the replies received by that cutoff was one hour.
What it suggests for builders’ merchants
12 of 14 valid branches answered by phone and none gave a price. 9 of the 12 asked three or more questions. A merchant is often the first desk a homeowner reaches, so the questions asked there matter.
Recommended referral process

Record a named owner when you refer the enquiry. The supplier can then see whether the installer accepted it and what next step the homeowner was given.
- Ask the qualifying questions once and carry the answers to every desk.
- Reply within minutes, at any hour, and say what happens next.
- Give a provisional estimate where the answers support one, and say what it covers.
- Make the handoff carry the details, so nobody asks the homeowner the same question twice.
- Let the supplier see who picked up each referral, and how quickly.
Questions to ask of your own network
- What does an enquiry at 8pm on a weekday get?
- How long until the homeowner hears from a person?
- Does the first reply include a price, and does it say what the price covers?
- Do the questions on the web form, phone and trade counter match?
- Can you see who picked up each referral, and how quickly?
For the full method and findings, see the overview. If any of this looks familiar, request a walkthrough.
Study notes: UK firms, October to November 2026. Small, dated samples with the denominator stated. Firms anonymised. Phone and web form results are counted separately, and phone figures are per firm. Reply times are elapsed hours from the first submission. Counts are as of 13 November 2026 and may still rise. Not a ranking of any firm.